Uncle Serge Baffles Us Once Again – Serge Lutens Vitriol d’Oeillet Perfume Review

Carnations

I’ve had a vase of purple carnations sat in my hallway for about two weeks now, they are suitably cheerful and they smell spicy and gorgeous. The problem with carnations is that they tend to hang around. Yes, they’re very beautiful but I’m at the point where I want them to move along so that I can refresh the vase with something else.

This is also how I feel about Vitriol d’Oeillet.

Serge Lutens has described Vitriol d’Oeillet as an ‘angry carnation’ and on the Serge Lutens website the description simply says “What is it, Doctor Jekyll?” [1] These descriptions lead me to believe that my tiny spray vial was going to unleash a huge, evil carnation monster that was going to eat me and ransack my house. A little farfetched I know, but I do have an active imagination.

What did come flying out of my little spray vial was something completely unexpected; A pretty and realistic spicy bunch of carnations. Just like the ones currently lurking in my hallway.

The Notes

Top: Pepper and Cloves
Heart: Carnation, Gillyflower and Woody Notes
Base: Sweet Notes and Powdery Notes [2]

How Does it Smell?

First things first, angry is not the word I would use to describe Vitriol d’Oeillet, and if I were to pick a perfume that displays an ‘angry carnation’ I would most likely pick something like Opium by Yves Saint Laurent, not Vitriol d’Oeillet. Secondly, we should all know by now that Uncle Serge likes to play tricks on us (Jeux de Peau anyone?) and we should always expect the unexpected.

The top notes are a fine mix of sweet and spicy, the pepper is relatively subdued compared to the clove which is quite prominent for the first half an hour or so. I do also detect a touch of ginger, which adds a bit of much needed zest to all of that spiciness.

Vitriol d’Oeillet’s heart is pure carnation and what the perfumer has cleverly done is pick out the individual nuances of the flower; the clove, the pepper, the ginger, the green stems and support these by adding them as individual notes, to give the overall impression of a vase off carnations. Carnation is a complex smell and credit has to be given for the photorealism of the scent.

Whilst smelling Vitriol d’Oeillet the same thought keeps running through my mind – ‘This is all very nice, but where is it going?’ and the answer is ‘nowhere’. Now, there’s nothing wrong with a fragrance being linear, just look at Feminité du Bois (another Serge creation) but I just don’t think Vitriol d’Oeillet is captivating enough to be linear, it feels as if it needs to develop, but it doesn’t. There is a tiny bit of development as Vitriol d’Oeillet moves towards the base, it becomes softer and ever so slightly powdery, but that’s as far as it goes

Part of me does wish that Vitriol d’Oeillet was that huge Godzilla carnation, it would have been fun to wear, but perhaps that would have been a bit too obvious and Uncle Serge doesn’t ‘do’ obvious.

Availability

Vitriol d’Oeillet is available in 50ml Eau de Parfum for £78.

Disclaimer

This review is based on a sample of Vitriol d’Oeillet provided by Escentual.com.

Image 1 The stubborn carnations in my hallway

[1] sergelutens.com

[2] osmoz.com

Advertisements

14 thoughts on “Uncle Serge Baffles Us Once Again – Serge Lutens Vitriol d’Oeillet Perfume Review

  1. I’m planning a review of Vitriol soon. I actually enjoy wearing it (I was the lucky recipient of a bottle at Ca Fleure Bon). 🙂
    I must say, I enjoy the fact that you never can guess what might await in a new bottle of an SL perfume. And that most of the time, it takes several wearings for me to get acquainted enought for love to develop.

    • To wear Serge is to expect the unexpected. I completely agree that his scents do take a few wearings, I fell in love with Tuberéuse Criminelle, Fleurs d’Oranger and Feminité du Bois only after repeated wearings.

      I look forward to reading your review of VdO!

  2. I SO wanted to love this because I was really excited from the moment I first found out about it, but what a disappointment! I wish I could enjoy it the way Ines does, as I’d love nothing more than a good carnation perfume. But I agree with you, there’s not enough going on to captivate. I wish it had deepened and turned into a rich spicy floral – too bad.

  3. I’m sad to say that a sample of VdO has yet to find a home in my decant/sample stash. I’ve heard so many mixed things about this fragrance that I just need to sniff it already. I love carnations, and I adore Serge, so…I am hoping this is a hit for me. I’ll try not to have too high expectations though!

  4. I really enjoyed this. I didn’t buy a FB because it generally didn’t get good reviews and that means that it will be available in great prices on ebay soon. I scored a bottle of Etro Dianthus at a very good price (blind) and I will write comparing the two when it arrives.

    One of the most unexpected offerings of uncle Serge is Vetiver Oriental. Being a vetiver hardcore fan it took me several months to find the vetiver in this one. Once I did find it though it was quite obvious. Can you imagine anyone else managing to create an oriental vetiver? Seems like a contradiction in terms.

    • I like your tactic there, waiting for a bottle on eBay sounds more then sensible!

      I’ve not tried Vetiver Oriental but I agree, it does seem like a contradiction, but that’s why we love Uncle Serge. Oddly, I’ve found that I get on with his florals much better than his orientals. Perhaps that’s just my personal taste.

  5. A little late to the party here!
    Nobody seems too excited by VdO…
    I love carnations – one of my favorite flowers. I love the way they look, feel, smell…but carnation perfumes do not smell good on me!
    I wonder if Uncle Serge’s carnation will work on me? Almost everything of his I’ve tried suits me quite well. Here’s hoping VdO works for me too!

  6. Pingback: And The Winner of The Candy Perfume Boy’s 100 Post Giveaway Is… | The Candy Perfume Boy

  7. Pingback: The Candy Perfume Boy’s 100th Post Giveaway! | The Candy Perfume Boy

Join the Discussion!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s