Essays in Purity and Austerity – Serge Lutens L’Eau & L’Eau Froide Perfume Reviews

Lutense

In 2010 the king of dark, brooding orientals and baroque florals, Serge Lutens, decided to launch an ‘anti-perfume’, a perfume that was designed to give you “a lasting sensation of wearing a ‘clean’ scent” [1]. Cue a huge outcry from the perfume community and hardcore Lutens fanboys (and girls); “He’s doing WHAT?! A clean scent?! Looks like Uncle Serge has finally lost it” they said.

Aristotle said “There is no great genius without a mixture of madness” and It is clear to me that Uncle Serge hasn’t lost it, instead it seems that he has quite the sense of humour. I can just see him sat in his office above his flagship boutique in the Palais Royal, chuckling away at the thought of the die-hard Lutenites trying L’Eau for the very first time. In my head he utters Miranda Hart’s catchphrase “such fun” as he tries to stifle his giggles.

This year Lutens has decided to take the joke that little bit further with the addition of L’Eau Froide, and as the name suggests, this time the water he is playing around with is is cold. Where L’Eau is described as a new kind of clean, L’Eau Froide is “Some fresh air in the rusty old water pipes.” [2] I told you he had a sense of humour! L’Eau was an essay in cleanliness and purity but L’Eau Froide is an essay in austerity and is just as gothic and Lutensien as you would hope it to be.

Serge Lutens L'Eau

L’Eau

The Notes

Aldehydes, Citrus, Magnolia, White Mint, Clary Sage, Ozonic Notes and Musk [3]

How Does it Smell?

L’Eau is a case of “It does exactly what it says on the tin” perfumery. It is a light, airy laundry musk with a surprising degree of tenacity and presence. It opens with a huge slug of aldehydes, but rather than shimmering or sparking as aldehydes so often do, instead they emanate a blinding white light akin to the gleam achieved when white cotton sheets drying in the sun catch the midday light.

A few drops of lemon are used in an almost undetectable way, their purpose is simply to emphasis the overall sense of ‘clean’. What I find most pleasing about L’Eau is the wonderfully creamy white floral accord set smack bang in the heart. I’m a sucker for a wonderfully creamy white floral accord and in L’Eau it is reminiscent of the snowy flowers of the beautiful gem that is Estée Lauder’s Pleasures.

As you would expect, the majority of the cleanliness in L’Eau comes from a great big, stonking white musk. White musk has a tendency to smell cheap and caustic at high volume, but in L’Eau all of the kinks and rough edges to the musk have been painstakingly worked out until it is beautifully smooth and well rounded. Despite having been smoothed out the musk never feels over-worked and the fact that, after an hour or so, it is all that remains on the skin doesn’t bother you for one minute.

L’Eau is an anti-perfume in two ways, firstly; it is a perfume designed for those who don’t want to wear perfume and just want to smell fresh and clean, secondly; it is the antithesis of all that is ‘Serge Lutens’, but it’s still of incredibly high quality and it wipes the floor with the many harsh and abrasive ‘clean’ perfumes that flood the market. Try this if you want to smell clean AND luxurious.

Serge Lutense L'Eau Froide

L’Eau Froide

The Notes

Somalia Incense, Marine Notes, Musks, Mint and Vetiver [4]

How Does it Smell?

L’Eau Froide is an unusual beast. It is clear from the outset that it is the distant cousin of L’Eau rather than an immediate relative. It takes the idea of the pure, clean quality of L’Eau down to the cold depths, where words like ‘clean’ and ‘pure’ are irrelevant.

The ice cold water that L’Eau Froide is supposed to represent is attributed to the use of incense from Somalia. The incense is, unsurprisingly, ice cold and incredibly austere, its menthol aspects are emphasised by mint and rosemary. It strikes the precise balance between menthol sweetness and a dry herbal quality that makes for a composition that is as severe as it is soft.

As L’Eau Froide develops it becomes more astringent and earthy thanks to the addition of vetiver. The dry down utilises a much softer and quieter musk than that used for L’Eau, and it doesn’t give a feeling of ‘clean’ or ‘pure’, instead it leaves the impression of something sparse, alien and cold.

L’Eau Froide is linear, unusual and very Lutensien. L’Eau, despite its high quality, does feel slightly alien within the Lutens collection, but L’Eau Froide shares that sombre quality of other Lutens perfumes such as Gris Clair and Iris Silver Mist. The startling thing about L’Eau Froide is that it isn’t evocative of cold water, instead it is evocative of a dry, arid landscape where the sky, earth and bare trees are all a pale shade of grey. It speaks of loneliness, silence and sorrow.

Availability

L’Eau and L’Eau Froide are available in 50ml and 100ml Eau de Parfum with prices ranging from £58-£85.79. They are both available through the Serge Lutens Website.

Disclaimer

This review is based on samples of L’Eau and L’Eau Froide supplied by Serge Lutens.
All links are for information purposes only and I am not affiliated with any third parties. 

[1] & [2] sergelutens.com
[3] & [4] basenotes.net 

Image 1 inmyotherworld.webatu.com
Image 2 ronrobinson.com
Image 3 mparis.ru

Advertisements

27 thoughts on “Essays in Purity and Austerity – Serge Lutens L’Eau & L’Eau Froide Perfume Reviews

  1. I was laughing at the thought of him sat above his salon saying ‘such fun’ in Miranda styley. I was not a fan of l’eau so not sure if I will find this one any better. I will try it should I stumble across it on my travels.:-)

  2. Chuckling at your reference to the way L’Eau Froide “wipes the floor” with mainstream clean scents!

    I definitely have my moments when a perfume speaking of “loneliness, silence and sorrow” might be just the ticket. My one venture into laundry musk territory was my purchase of L’Artisan L’Ete en Douce (an arch albatross in my fridge), but it was waaaay too musky at the expense of everything else. I am well and truly intrigued to try this one now. However, he original L’Eau by SL only had joke value for me!

      • I am fascinated to try the L’Eau Froide – but is it your only sample? I would gladly send it back afterwards if so. I don’t have one on the way, not that I know of!

  3. I’ve requested my sample of L’Eau Froide but didn’t feel much interest until I read your review. I like the sound of the quiet, chilly incense.

    I think of SL as a mischievious imp!

  4. Ooooh, cold incense? Count me in as another person who wasn’t feeling any interest until I read your review. (Uhhh, is this where I admit the only SL I’ve ever tried is ISM? Shhh, don’t tell anyone.)

  5. Am I the only one who likes L’Eau more than L’Eau Froide? The latter seems a bit out of place in this line, a bit too familiar, “been there, done that” kind of way…

  6. Well, fascinating.

    And I admit that I’m not that big a fan of “clean” scents… or “dry and austere” scents, either, for that matter. If a sample comes my way I’ll try it with an open mind, thanks to your clearheaded reviews here. Tarleisio’s review of L’Eau Froide was a joy, too.

    I was nonplussed by the whole “OH NO UNCLE SERGE IS SELLING OUT” pandemonium when L’Eau was released. The guy puts out such straaaaange fragrances, why *wouldn’t* he have a sense of humor? Why *wouldn’t* he do something off the wall just to prove that he could?

  7. I had the lucky chance to win a sample of L’Eau Froide in a draw and have worn it twice: I can’t say it’s a fragrance in my chords (but Uncle Serge and I don’t get on very well, I’m afraid- except for Bornéo 1834), the aquatic sensation being too overwhelming on my skin.
    Anyway, I find its swampy- mouthwash opening accord rather interesting. I’m not sure I can detect incense, though!

  8. I am dying, DYING to try L’Eau Froide, but L’Eau?! OH GOOD LORD. I have never cried as much as I did the first time I wore it. I have an adorable mini bottle of it that gathers dust somewhere. I just can’t wear it! It’s just not a Serge to me.

  9. How interesting … I found L’Eau Froide crisp and icy like the very first morning of Spring, and not at all “dry, arid or sombre”. (Though I may now that you’ve mentioned it. 🙂 And I must admit I’m enjoying the unusual cool facet of this frankincense (& in fact the whole eau) much more than I thought I would after the previous L’Eau, (which did leave me cold unfortunately :o). …
    I’m not really into “clean frags” at all, … though I suspect L’Eau Froide might just become my go to frag for this summer. (Probably kept in the fridge too for that little extra jolt … 🙂

    • Keeping bottles in the fridge during summer is a very good idea. I used to do that with my bottle of Mugler Cologne, I shall have to start again in the summer. I hate the heat!

      It’s interesting that we’ve had two very different takes on this one. Are you going to be getting a bottle?

      • Unless something “cooler” comes along and steals the spotlight by summer ;), I might just. It’s so completely different from anything else I have in my wardrobe that I think I could do with one. (I’m always much thinner on the ground when it comes to “summery scents”).

  10. Pingback: Waterlogged Cotton – Serge Lutens Laine de Verre Perfume Review | The Candy Perfume Boy

Join the Discussion!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s