Is Gaudiness the Closest Thing to Godliness? – Versace Eros Perfume Review

Versace Eros

Versace Eros

As a fashion brand I have the greatest respect for Versace (admittedly less-so with Donatella at the helm) – they know how to make gaudy look glamorous and are at their very best when they are being as showy as possible. As a perfume brand Versace is less attractive, again their older stuff is good (I’ll always have a soft spot for Blue Jeans and Versace Woman, and Blonde is pretty awesome) but their newer stuff is very much lacklustre at best.

So it was with mixed expectations that I approached the brand’s latest masculine offering ‘Eros’. On the surface Eros appears to have everything you would want in a Versace fragrance – tacky bottle (it’s positively wonderful in its tackiness), ridiculous, over-the-top advertising (see here) and a Tanorexic muscly adonis fronting the whole thing – but as we all know in the world of fragrance, appearances can be deceiving.

Eros takes its name from Greek mythology, specifically the Greek God of Love. Created by perfumer Aurélien Guichard (Bond No 9 Chinatown and all of the new Robert Piguet fragrances and re-issues) Eros is described by Donatella Versace as being for “a man who is own master and who defends his own ideas and goals. He is a hero.” We know exactly what Donatella’s idea of a hero looks like but what does he smell like?

Gratuitous Man Candy...

Gratuitous Man Candy…

The Notes

Top: Apple, Mint and Lemon
Heart: Geranium, Tonka Bean and Ambroxan
Base: Vanilla, Vetiver, Atlas Cedar and Oakmoss

How Does it Smell?

Eros opens with an incredibly ordinary blast of lemon and apple. Each note seems to want to out-blare the other resulting in a citrus din that if applied in sufficient quantities could very easily cause a headache. There is a herbal element lurking in the background that fails to cut through the astringent quality of the citrus, which is a shame because frankly it would have been a relief.

Vanilla follows very quickly and boy does it make its presence known – this is full-on, attention-seeking vanilla at its strongest and most relentless. Mixed with the citrus the vanilla feels very sweet but not very creamy, the overall texture being quite powdery and whilst it doesn’t feel top-notch quality wise there are interesting burned and toasted sugar facets to it that could be something quite special if things were better balanced.

The base notes promise vetiver, cedar and oakmoss, all three of which appear to be taking an extended leave of absence. Perhaps the vanilla murdered them all and hid their bodies under the floorboard? Whatever happened they’re not present and Eros pretty much finishes as it started – loud and proud with apple, lemon and vanilla.

Eros is a tricky beast, it feels as tacky as you would expect a Versace fragrance to feel but it doesn’t achieve godly gaudiness and isn’t anything you haven’t sniffed before – in fact, it’s very much like a lot of things already out there. It’s main problem lies solely with its volume, it blares out a relentless stream of citrus and vanilla that is so loud it knocks out all of those interesting nuances that could have made for something quite special. I’d never thought I’d say this but Donatella, perhaps you should tone it down a bit love?


Eros is available in 50ml (£46) and 100ml (£62) Eau de Toilette. Matching body products are also available.

Image 1 Image 2 Notes and Quotes via


34 thoughts on “Is Gaudiness the Closest Thing to Godliness? – Versace Eros Perfume Review

  1. Ugh how much of a yawn-fest is “a man who is own master and who defends his own ideas and goals. He is a hero.” It’s like these people at the helm haven’t a shred of originality or even imagination.

  2. I let my husband think he’s his own master sometimes. I want to sniff this but more out of curiosity than an actual interest in the scent. Apple in perfume isn’t high on my list of favorites.

  3. I can’t wait to see this bottle in the flesh ! It’s a beauty in the print and I’m hoping one day it will join my 30ml dreamer , a old fave from the late 90s and a bottle that holds a special place in my heart. But…….. Only at a very, very, very discounted price!
    Thanks for your thoughts, a little gaud every now and then can be fun. EltonJohn made a career out of it.
    Oh and LOVE Blue Jeans 😉

  4. I don’t mind a bit of apple in my frags. {All About Eve by Joop! is a fave},however,this reads like it might just be too much. Wondering if soon we shall be reading of ‘passenger killed due to Eros type tales from you, Thomas. From the above pic ,one assumes its aimed at the 20 something nightclubbers.

  5. Pingback: El Dios Eros de Versace. | Concentrado Creativo

  6. I agree with Jules, some of the men I used to know would have lapped this stuff up about 35 years ago, but alas, I fear it has missed its moment…

  7. Pingback: Jagged Lines – Bottega Veneta Pour Homme Perfume Review | The Candy Perfume Boy

  8. Pingback: The Candies 2013: The Very Best and Very Worst Perfumes of 2013 | The Candy Perfume Boy

  9. Pingback: Flesh Tones – Narciso Rodriguez NARCISO Perfume Review | The Candy Perfume Boy

  10. Pingback: Fragrant Hopes and Dreams for 2015 | The Candy Perfume Boy

  11. Pingback: A Golden Opportunity, Missed – Versace Eros Pour Femme Perfume Review | The Candy Perfume Boy

Join the Discussion!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s